Cognitive Simulation Versus Functional AI: Learning from Aviation History

Historical Failures of Simulation-Based AI

Dartmouth Conference Optimism and Reality

Early AI researchers made bold predictions. Machines thinking as effectively as humans would require at most one coming generation. ¹ They were spectacularly wrong. Not because they lacked talent or dedication, but because they fundamentally misunderstood the challenge.

The biggest problem with early efforts was we don't understand how the human mind works well enough to create simulations. ¹ You cannot simulate what you cannot comprehend. Neural networks, expert systems, symbolic reasoning... all attempted to replicate human cognition without understanding its underlying mechanisms.

Aviation history offers instructive parallels. The Wright Brothers didn't succeed by exactly imitating bird flight; instead, birds provided the idea that led to accurate aerodynamics that eventually led to human flight. ¹ Their first successful powered flight occurred December 17, 1903. ² That date now marks Wright Brothers Day internationally, celebrating breakthrough achieved through understanding rather than imitation.

Computational Power as Understanding Substitute

The reason AI is somewhat effective today is because hardware finally became powerful enough to support calculations. ¹ This represents both progress and admission of defeat. We're compensating for incomplete understanding with brute computational force.

Modern machine learning exemplifies this approach. Deep neural networks process millions of parameters through billions of calculations. They achieve results without anyone fully understanding why they work. The computational muscle compensates for theoretical gaps that early researchers thought they could bridge with elegant algorithms.

The Wright Flyer 1 demonstrated that Orville and Wilbur Wright understood aerodynamic principles sufficiently for powered flight. ³ They built theory before scaling power. Contemporary AI reverses this sequence, building powerful systems before achieving cognitive theory. This works, but raises questions about long-term sustainability and advancement potential.

Functional Achievement Through Process Understanding

Goal-Oriented AI Development

The goal is to fly. Both birds and humans achieve this goal, but they use different approaches. ¹ This statement encapsulates the functional AI philosophy. Success means achieving objectives, not replicating biological processes.

Self-driving cars illustrate this principle perfectly. They must act humanly, not rationally, because traffic is not rational. ¹ A perfectly rational vehicle following traffic laws precisely would get stuck somewhere because other drivers don't follow laws precisely. ¹ Functional success requires adaptation to real-world conditions, not theoretical perfection.

Wright Brothers (the construction company) implemented AIoT safety technology in September 2025, recognizing that real-world environments demand practical solutions over theoretical ideals. ⁴ Their fleet operates in construction zones where human behavior becomes maximally unpredictable. Functional AI succeeds here where simulation-based approaches would fail.

Theory of Mind and Environmental Adaptation

The Total Turing Test includes physical contact and perceptual capability interrogation, meaning computers must also use computer vision and robotics to succeed. ¹ This expanded assessment recognizes AI must interact with physical reality, not just process abstract symbols.

A machine that can assess necessary goals and potential goals of other entities has some reasonable understanding. ¹ This theory of mind capability bridges functional achievement and cognitive simulation. Autonomous systems need to predict human behavior without fully simulating human consciousness.

The Wright Brothers succeeded by understanding the process birds use, creating aerodynamics, not by imitation. ¹ Seven fascinating facts about the Wright Brothers reveal their methodical, process-oriented approach to achieving powered flight. ⁵ Modern AI development must follow similar methodology. Understanding cognitive processes enables functional achievement. Perfect simulation remains unnecessary and probably impossible. The aviation pioneers proved that different mechanisms can achieve identical goals through process understanding rather than biological replication.

Daftar Pustaka